Applied learning18 practical cases
Case 1: Return after death of proprietor
Section: 302
Facts: A person or organisation faces legal representative. The working paper identifies capacity, relevant income or assets, liability limits, forms and continuing conditions.
Approach: Notify the department promptly, identify all legal representatives, estate assets, pending returns and proceedings, and avoid personal/estate fund mixing.
Control: Identify legal capacity and taxpayer whose income is involved.; Reconcile entity documents, books, beneficiaries or partners.; Monitor registration, liability and recovery consequences.
Case 2: Trustee as representative assessee
Section: 303
Facts: A person or organisation faces representative assessee. The working paper identifies capacity, relevant income or assets, liability limits, forms and continuing conditions.
Approach: Representative status is a collection and assessment mechanism. Identify whose income is taxed, in what capacity and with what recovery rights.
Control: Identify legal capacity and taxpayer whose income is involved.; Reconcile entity documents, books, beneficiaries or partners.; Monitor registration, liability and recovery consequences.
Case 3: Recovery limited to estate
Section: 304
Facts: A former partner receives a recovery notice. The response maps the firm's period, partnership dates, tax demand and joint-liability provision.
Approach: Identify the liability period, statutory capacity, recovery ceiling, defences, indemnity rights and supporting evidence.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 4: Representative recovery from beneficiary
Section: 305
Facts: A special liability applies to one income bucket. The computation separately identifies that bucket and prevents double taxation or duplicate credit.
Approach: Reconcile the taxpayer, tax base, rate, deductions, credits, timing, reporting and recovery provisions before computing liability.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 5: Indian agent of non-resident
Section: 306
Facts: A person or organisation faces who may be regarded as agent. The working paper identifies capacity, relevant income or assets, liability limits, forms and continuing conditions.
Approach: Agent status can create filing and payment duties without making the income the agent's own. Review contracts, authority, payments and Indian nexus.
Control: Identify legal capacity and taxpayer whose income is involved.; Reconcile entity documents, books, beneficiaries or partners.; Monitor registration, liability and recovery consequences.
Case 6: Unknown beneficiary shares
Section: 307
Facts: A special liability applies to one income bucket. The computation separately identifies that bucket and prevents double taxation or duplicate credit.
Approach: Reconcile the taxpayer, tax base, rate, deductions, credits, timing, reporting and recovery provisions before computing liability.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 7: Oral trust tax
Section: 308
Facts: A special liability applies to one income bucket. The computation separately identifies that bucket and prevents double taxation or duplicate credit.
Approach: Reconcile the taxpayer, tax base, rate, deductions, credits, timing, reporting and recovery provisions before computing liability.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 8: AOP member share
Section: 309
Facts: A receipt has both corpus and service elements. Separate documentation and accounting determine the correct treatment.
Approach: Prepare a source-to-head schedule and test character, recipient, timing, exclusions, anti-duplication and evidence.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 9: Executor administration period
Section: 312
Facts: A taxpayer encounters an issue concerning executor. The working paper maps the facts, statutory conditions and prescribed procedure before any position is taken.
Approach: Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 10: Business succession
Section: 313
Facts: A taxpayer encounters an issue concerning succession to business or profession otherwise than on death. The working paper maps the facts, statutory conditions and prescribed procedure before any position is taken.
Approach: Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 11: Court-approved reorganisation
Section: 314
Facts: A taxpayer encounters an issue concerning effect of order of tribunal or court in respect of business reorganisation. The working paper maps the facts, statutory conditions and prescribed procedure before any position is taken.
Approach: Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 12: HUF partition claim
Section: 315
Facts: A person or organisation faces assessment after partition of hindu undivided family. The working paper identifies capacity, relevant income or assets, liability limits, forms and continuing conditions.
Approach: Family-law division and tax recognition are separate. File the claim, evidence assets and members, and obtain the assessment finding.
Control: Identify legal capacity and taxpayer whose income is involved.; Reconcile entity documents, books, beneficiaries or partners.; Monitor registration, liability and recovery consequences.
Case 13: Non-resident shipping voyage
Section: 316
Facts: A taxpayer encounters an issue concerning shipping business of non-residents. The working paper maps the facts, statutory conditions and prescribed procedure before any position is taken.
Approach: Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 14: Person preparing to leave India
Section: 317
Facts: An assessment proposes a mismatch addition. The taxpayer reconciles return, books, third-party statement and supporting vouchers before the hearing.
Approach: Build a notice-to-issue matrix covering jurisdiction, limitation, evidence, hearing, computation and final order service.
Control: Record the applicable person, event and tax year.; Link every conclusion to statutory conditions and primary evidence.; Track prescribed form, authority, limitation and downstream consequence.
Case 15: Private-company director recovery
Section: 323
Facts: A person or organisation faces liability of directors of private company. The working paper identifies capacity, relevant income or assets, liability limits, forms and continuing conditions.
Approach: Director liability is secondary but serious. Preserve governance records showing diligence, non-negligence and absence of breach of duty.
Control: Identify legal capacity and taxpayer whose income is involved.; Reconcile entity documents, books, beneficiaries or partners.; Monitor registration, liability and recovery consequences.
Case 16: Firm deed and assessment status
Section: 325
Facts: A person or organisation faces assessment as a firm. The working paper identifies capacity, relevant income or assets, liability limits, forms and continuing conditions.
Approach: Review the partnership deed before year-end changes, and reconcile partner identity, shares, remuneration and interest to the return.
Control: Identify legal capacity and taxpayer whose income is involved.; Reconcile entity documents, books, beneficiaries or partners.; Monitor registration, liability and recovery consequences.
Case 17: NPO accumulation
Section: 342
Facts: A person or organisation faces accumulated income. The working paper identifies capacity, relevant income or assets, liability limits, forms and continuing conditions.
Approach: Accumulation is a controlled deferral. File Form 109, state a precise purpose, ring-fence funds and monitor the use-by date.
Control: Identify legal capacity and taxpayer whose income is involved.; Reconcile entity documents, books, beneficiaries or partners.; Monitor registration, liability and recovery consequences.
Case 18: NPO merger
Section: 354A
Facts: A person or organisation faces merger of registered non-profit organisation in certain cases. The working paper identifies capacity, relevant income or assets, liability limits, forms and continuing conditions.
Approach: Test objects, registration, assets, liabilities and successor compliance before the merger; do not assume every charitable merger is neutral.
Control: Identify legal capacity and taxpayer whose income is involved.; Reconcile entity documents, books, beneficiaries or partners.; Monitor registration, liability and recovery consequences.
Professional Q&A36 questions
1. What is the core purpose of section 302?
Notify the department promptly, identify all legal representatives, estate assets, pending returns and proceedings, and avoid personal/estate fund mixing.
Sections: 302
2. What is the core purpose of section 303?
Representative status is a collection and assessment mechanism. Identify whose income is taxed, in what capacity and with what recovery rights.
Sections: 303
3. What is the core purpose of section 304?
Identify the liability period, statutory capacity, recovery ceiling, defences, indemnity rights and supporting evidence.
Sections: 304
4. What is the core purpose of section 305?
Reconcile the taxpayer, tax base, rate, deductions, credits, timing, reporting and recovery provisions before computing liability.
Sections: 305
5. What is the core purpose of section 306?
Agent status can create filing and payment duties without making the income the agent's own. Review contracts, authority, payments and Indian nexus.
Sections: 306
6. What is the core purpose of section 307?
Reconcile the taxpayer, tax base, rate, deductions, credits, timing, reporting and recovery provisions before computing liability.
Sections: 307
7. What is the core purpose of section 308?
Reconcile the taxpayer, tax base, rate, deductions, credits, timing, reporting and recovery provisions before computing liability.
Sections: 308
8. What is the core purpose of section 309?
Prepare a source-to-head schedule and test character, recipient, timing, exclusions, anti-duplication and evidence.
Sections: 309
9. What is the core purpose of section 310?
Prepare a source-to-head schedule and test character, recipient, timing, exclusions, anti-duplication and evidence.
Sections: 310
10. What is the core purpose of section 311?
Reconcile the taxpayer, tax base, rate, deductions, credits, timing, reporting and recovery provisions before computing liability.
Sections: 311
11. What is the core purpose of section 312?
Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Sections: 312
12. What is the core purpose of section 313?
Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Sections: 313
13. What is the core purpose of section 314?
Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Sections: 314
14. What is the core purpose of section 315?
Family-law division and tax recognition are separate. File the claim, evidence assets and members, and obtain the assessment finding.
Sections: 315
15. What is the core purpose of section 316?
Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Sections: 316
16. What is the core purpose of section 317?
Build a notice-to-issue matrix covering jurisdiction, limitation, evidence, hearing, computation and final order service.
Sections: 317
17. What is the core purpose of section 318?
Build a notice-to-issue matrix covering jurisdiction, limitation, evidence, hearing, computation and final order service.
Sections: 318
18. What is the core purpose of section 319?
Build a notice-to-issue matrix covering jurisdiction, limitation, evidence, hearing, computation and final order service.
Sections: 319
19. What is the core purpose of section 320?
Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Sections: 320
20. What is the core purpose of section 321?
Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Sections: 321
21. What is the core purpose of section 322?
Identify the person, event, period, conditions, authority, evidence and consequence before applying the provision.
Sections: 322
22. What is the core purpose of section 323?
Director liability is secondary but serious. Preserve governance records showing diligence, non-negligence and absence of breach of duty.
Sections: 323
23. What is the core purpose of section 324?
Reconcile the taxpayer, tax base, rate, deductions, credits, timing, reporting and recovery provisions before computing liability.
Sections: 324
24. What is the core purpose of section 325?
Review the partnership deed before year-end changes, and reconcile partner identity, shares, remuneration and interest to the return.
Sections: 325
25. Is representative income the representative’s own income?
No. The person is assessed in a representative capacity for another person’s income.
Sections: Chapter XVII
26. Does a legal representative have unlimited personal liability?
The section and estate/conduct rules determine the ceiling; personal exposure is not assumed automatically.
Sections: Chapter XVII
27. Can a non-resident’s Indian agent be assessed without opportunity?
The statutory agent route includes the applicable procedural safeguards.
Sections: Chapter XVII
28. Is a family partition automatically recognised for tax?
No. Tax recognition requires the statutory inquiry and finding.
Sections: Chapter XVII
29. Does retirement erase partner exposure for old firm tax?
Not automatically. Joint-liability provisions and the relevant period must be reviewed.
Sections: Chapter XVII
30. What is the entry gate for the NPO regime?
Registration under section 332 through Rule 181 and the prescribed form/order route.
Sections: Chapter XVII
31. Is every donation corpus income?
No. Corpus status requires the statutory direction and compliance with the special rules.
Sections: Chapter XVII
32. Can accumulated income be used for any later purpose?
No. Purpose, period, investment and change-of-purpose rules apply.
Sections: Chapter XVII
33. Are commercial receipts always fatal for an NPO?
No, but sections 345-346 impose incidence, purpose, books and quantitative tests.
Sections: Chapter XVII
34. What form supports deemed application?
Form 108 under Rule 184.
Sections: Chapter XVII
35. What form supports accumulation?
Form 109 under Rule 185.
Sections: Chapter XVII
36. What is accreted-income tax designed to protect?
The public-benefit asset base when an NPO converts, merges impermissibly or fails asset-transfer requirements.
Sections: Chapter XVII