Accounting Policy and Estimate Memo: AS 1 and AS 5 Evidence File
Content updated: . Earlier named review dates refer to the historical edition; this update is not a new named professional review.
Reviewed by CA Nikhil Gupta · Last reviewed: 20 June 2026
Accounting policies and estimates should be written before disputes arise. The memo explains how management recognises revenue, expenses, assets and provisions consistently.
For a separate tax-classification evidence example, see GST Classification Dispute: HSN, SAC and Rate Evidence File.
Detailed analysis
AS 1 deals with accounting policy disclosure and AS 5 deals with net profit/loss, prior-period items and accounting policy changes. A memo helps ensure consistent treatment across periods and audit teams.
Practical example
Company changes depreciation estimate for servers after migrating to cloud. Finance documents reason, technical evidence, impact on current/future depreciation and approval before updating the fixed asset module.
Evidence and control checklist
| Area | What to check | Evidence to save |
|---|---|---|
| Policy inventory | Revenue, inventory, PPE, provisions and FX policies. | Accounting policy manual. |
| Estimates | Useful life, bad debts, NRV, provisions and fair estimates. | Estimate workings and assumptions. |
| Changes | Policy/estimate changes and impact. | Change memo and approval. |
| Prior-period items | Nature, amount and correction logic. | Prior-period analysis and journal support. |
| Disclosure | Financial statement note support. | Disclosure checklist and draft note. |
Common mistakes
- Policy copied from old FS without current review.
- No support for estimates.
- Changing estimate to hit target profit.
- Not disclosing material changes.
- No approval for policy change.
Official reference framework
Based only on official India Code, MCA and ICAI source pages listed below. Check the latest Companies Act, Schedule III, accounting standards, Ind AS/AS applicability and auditor guidance before closing or filing.
Official sources used
Content and source check: 2 November 2026. Use the complete notified standard and the company’s applicable reporting framework. The specific source trail below distinguishes accounting requirements, company-law presentation and suggested internal controls. Earlier June dates describe the historical edition, not a new named professional review.
- ICAI: Accounting Standards as on February 1, 2022
- Gazette: notified AS 5, complete text, physical pages 351–354
- ICSI: current section 129 — financial statements
- India Code: dated Schedule III compilation, physical pages 283–357
Keep policy, estimate and error decisions separate
First confirm the company’s notified AS or Ind AS framework. For the AS framework, AS 1 addresses significant accounting-policy disclosure; its fundamental assumptions are going concern, consistency and accrual. Disclose a departure from a fundamental assumption. Disclosing a policy does not make an inappropriate treatment acceptable.
AS 5 paragraphs 20–27 distinguish a revised estimate based on new information from correction of an earlier error. Apply the estimate effect to the current period, or current and future periods, as appropriate. In the server-to-cloud example, preserve the technical useful-life evidence, effective assessment date, remaining carrying amount, current/future depreciation working and material disclosures; do not rewrite the old estimate simply to achieve a profit target.
A policy change needs the grounds in AS 5 paragraph 29: a statutory requirement, compliance with an accounting standard, or a more appropriate presentation. Record why the new policy gives more relevant or reliable information, the material effect and disclosures, and any specific transitional provisions. A new type of transaction or one previously immaterial is not automatically a policy change under paragraph 31.
Management owns the accounting judgement and its approval process. Keep the auditor’s independent evaluation separate. Schedule III supports presentation and disclosure; it does not prescribe the company’s internal memo owner or approve a policy choice.
FAQs
Sources and update trail
Source check and content update: 2 November 2026. Apply the company’s actual notified AS or Ind AS framework. Suggested owner, monthly workflow and evidence-folder choices are internal controls; Schedule III is presentation context.
- Notified AS 1, complete text: physical pages 330–333
- Notified AS 5, complete text: physical pages 351–354
- ICAI current company-AS rules and amendment owner
- Current ICSI section 129 — reporting-framework and financial-statement context
Read the linked notified standard with applicable amendments and the company’s reporting framework. The 2022 ICAI index is a dated reference edition; the company-AS owner links rules and amendments. The India Code PDF is a dated compilation. Institutional and publication portals provide further navigation rather than deciding an accounting treatment.
Retained supplementary references
- www.icai.org
- India Code: dated Schedule III compilation, physical pages 283–357
- ICAI: Accounting Standards as on February 1, 2022
- ICSI: current section 129 — financial statements
- Gazette: notified AS 5, complete text, physical pages 351–354
- ICAI: current company Accounting Standards rules and amendments
- ICAI Accounting Standards publication portal
- India Code: Companies Act PDF compilation (dated)
Original bylines and earlier named review dates refer to the historical edition. This source/content update is not a new named professional sign-off.